Costs

Roof coating vs full replacement

Roof coatings are often marketed as a cheap alternative to replacement. Sometimes they are. But a coating over a roof that's failing underneath is wasted money.

Coating / restorationReplacement
Planning cost~$1.50–$4.50 / sq ft (plus repairs)~$4–$14 / sq ft plus tear-off
Extra lifeTypically 10–15 years, can be recoatedTypically 20–30 years
NeedsSound roof, mostly dry insulationAny condition
DisruptionLow, no tear-offHigher, tear-off and noise

Ask for a moisture survey first

An infrared or core-cut survey shows how much of the insulation is wet. If only small areas are wet, they can be replaced before coating. If much of the roof is wet, replacement is usually the better long-term choice.

Questions for a coating contractor

  • Which coating (silicone, acrylic, polyurethane) and why for this roof?
  • What dry film thickness, and how will it be verified?
  • Which manufacturer warranty, and what does it exclude?
  • How will seams, flashings and ponding areas be reinforced?

More guides

Get free roofing quotes